Swap in an Easy Margarine Substitute for a Healthier Recipe (2024)

• Recipes & Cooking
• How to Cook
• Substitutions

It's no secret that our Test Kitchen loves a good cookie or pound cake recipe loaded with a buttery flavor. But what about margarine? Before we get into what kind of margarine substitute to use, it's important to know fats and oils add flavor and contribute to the texture of your baked goods. Since margarine is found in the same section of your grocery store, you might be wondering if you can easily swap margarine with butter or another butter substitute in a recipe.

The short answer is while there is no exact rule for substituting the fats in your recipes, you'll likely be able to use butter or shortening as a one-to-one swap for margarine. In addition to butter, we're sharing some easy (and healthier swaps) for when you need a margarine substitute right away.

Margarine Substitutes

While oil provides moisture to many baking recipes (we're looking at you, olive oil cake!), you need your margarine substitute to be in a solid form so the proper amount of air can be incorporated. For example, you want to be able to cream your butter and sugar together to get your chocolate chip cookies with the perfect texture. For this reason, cooking oils such as vegetable or canola are not recommended substitutes for margarine.

Substitute Butter for Margarine

The easiest, fool-proof way to ensure your baked goods will turn out the most similar is using butter. For 1 cup margarine, substitute 1 cup butter or 1 cup shortening plus ¼ teaspoon salt.

Substitute Oil for Margarine

It's easy to swap in coconut oil, olive oil, canola oil, avocado oil, or vegetable oil for margarine. In most recipes, oil is substituted for margarine at a 3:4 ratio. This accounts for any water or other ingredients in the margarine. So, for every cup of margarine in the recipe, use 3/4 cup of oil.

Healthy Margarine Substitutes

For 1 cup margarine, substitute 1 cup of the following:

• 1 cup softened cream cheese (or one 8 oz. block) or reduced-fat cream cheese, which has fewer calories and fat.
• 1 cup 60% to 70% vegetable or olive oil spread, which are trans-fat-free.
• 1 cup tofu (best in brownies).
• 1 cup baby prunes (best in dark baked goods due to color).
• 1 cup unsweetened applesauce, which cuts the fat and adds vitamin C.

More Cooking and Baking Substitutions

Keep the healthy kick going by learning more ways to bake with less fat. Or download our free healthy substitutions chart to keep even more ideas on hand for your next meal.

• Every Vinegar Substitute You Need to Save Your Recipes
• The Best Substitutions for Heavy Cream for Sweet or Savory Recipes
• How to Substitute Whole-Wheat Flour for All-Purpose Flour
• 5 Sour Cream Substitutes for Baking or Cooking with the Same Tang